Design and product review
Method: rendered all three deliverables in Chrome at 1280 and 390 wide (full-page screenshots), clicked through the landing demo, the dashboard sheet and dark mode, tested prefers-reduced-motion, checked console errors (none), and ran a design linter over the landing page. Findings are in priority order. Status: Fixed, or Open (deferred with a reason).
Priority problems
- The wordmark contradicted the brand idea. PLAN.md says the crema dot sits between the two p's, but every deliverable rendered "do.ppio". The logo is the single most repeated brand asset and it was wrong in four places. Fixed: "dop.pio" in style guide, landing, dashboard.
- Dashboard "New booking" did nothing. It is the one primary action on every screen and was a dead button. Fixed: opens a sheet with a validated form (friendly error copy), adds a pending booking, switches to Schedule, and confirms with a status message. Bookings now live in app state, so Overview, Schedule and Roster all update.
- Schedule view was unusable at common widths. Overlapping bookings (Sat 2 pm and 3 pm) drew on top of each other, and the calendar needed horizontal scrolling at 1280 so Saturday and Sunday were cut off. Fixed: overlap lanes, a narrower detail panel beside the calendar from
xl, smaller minimum width.
- Dashboard on mobile clipped the bookings table (Total and Status cut off) and stat cards stacked into a long single column. Fixed: Total hidden on small screens, status moves under the booking name, stats in a 2x2 grid.
- Dark mode was keyboard-only and partly broken. The only toggle was a hidden "press d" hint, and the Sam and Ines calendar blocks (roast, mocha) vanished against the dark surface. Fixed: visible toggle in the sidebar, lighter tones for those blocks in dark.
- Landing booking preview broke its own promise on mobile. The price lived below the form, so changing a chip showed nothing. The headline also said "Three taps" over a four-step form and hyphenated awkwardly ("first-/rate"). Fixed: a sticky quote pill on mobile, new headline "A first-rate flat white, booked in a minute.", balanced heading wrapping site-wide.
- Pricing cards did not connect to the demo. "Choose" jumped to the form without selecting the package. Fixed: selects the matching length and updates the quote.
- Radio-style chips were not keyboard-correct. Every chip was a tab stop. Fixed: roving tabindex plus the existing arrow keys. The quote total is now a status region instead of the whole panel being live, which was noisy for screen readers.
- Style guide was thin against the plan. Iconography, imagery and the dashboard mapping were in PLAN.md but absent from the guide; the swatch grid left an orphan row; the plan said eight colours and the guide shipped nine. Fixed: added Icons and imagery and Dashboard mapping sections (with colour to shadcn variable table), tidied grids, PLAN.md now says nine colours.
- Cross-deliverable data drift. Priya's party was "Sat 14" on the landing and "Sat 21" in the dashboard, with different titles. Fixed: aligned.
- Landing polish (from the linter and critique): five uppercase tracked eyebrows repeating the headings, a 23-word hero paragraph, a marquee that cannot be paused, a card with both border and heavy shadow, disabled buttons shown by opacity alone. Fixed: eyebrows removed where redundant and the rest in sentence case, hero copy cut to two short sentences, marquee pauses on hover and focus, border removed, disabled state now changes fill and ink.
- Phone mock on the landing was mostly empty. Fixed: second booking and a barista message so it demonstrates "manage anywhere".
Open (not fixed)
- Copy volume: the landing is about 570 words against a 450-word lint budget. The occasion bullet lists and FAQ could be cut or moved behind interaction.
- No real photography or illustration depth: the imagery is CSS/SVG only (a known assumption). A hero photo would sell the "tactile" brand more than the cup does.
- Straight apostrophes in static copy rather than typographic ones.
- Dashboard: no calendar week navigation, table rows are not clickable, and the narrow overlap lanes truncate titles (the detail panel carries the full text). The mock revenue stats do not recompute chart bars from added bookings.
- Landing nav hides its links under 760px with no menu; the Reserve button and in-page scroll cover the main path.
- Fonts depend on Google Fonts on the static pages, with fallbacks.