Critical review of Doppio
Reviewed as a senior brand and product designer would, against PLAN.md and across the three deliverables. Evidence: rendered screenshots (desktop, 500px mobile, reduced motion, dark and light), a design-rule detector, and a read of the code. Items are in priority order. Status shows what was done about each in this pass.
P1: Breaks the brief or the user
- The dashboard opens in dark mode for most people.
PLAN.md (A7) says light is primary, but the theme provider defaults to system, so every screenshot and any dark-OS user got the espresso theme and never saw the crema brand. The dashboard also reads less like the landing page and style guide than it should. Fix: default to light; dark stays a toggle.
- Landing pricing is inconsistent with itself and with the dashboard. The pricing section says Cart $480 and Full bar $890 with guests included, but the booking preview priced a full bar at $820 and added a hidden per-guest surcharge, which contradicts "fixed prices, nothing hidden", the core promise. Dashboard totals use $890. Fix: one price table: experience sets the base, full bar adds $410, no per-guest charge; capacity is a limit, not a price.
- Invented proof on a product that is only launching. "12,400+ events poured, 310,000 cups, 86 baristas" and named testimonials read as real traction. The brief says we are launching. A designer would not ship fabricated claims. Fix: replace the stats strip with true product facts (about 60 seconds to book, 48 hours of free changes, up to 150 guests, 4 baristas' worth of styles), and label the quotes as early feedback samples.
3b. Dead controls in the dashboard. "New booking" does nothing, and pending bookings can't be actioned, so the "upcoming bookings" table is read-only decoration for an operator whose real job is confirming and rostering. Fix: remove the dead button; add Confirm and Cancel row actions that update bookings, stats and schedule live.
P2: Accessibility and interaction quality
- Booking preview focus and semantics. Time and barista buttons are re-rendered with
innerHTML, so keyboard focus is lost after every selection; aria-live on the whole card announces everything on every change; the calendar is role="grid" without row and cell roles; step changes do not move focus; the arrow-key handler is a hack. Fix: restore focus after render, a dedicated live region for the total and confirmation, role="group" for the calendar, focus the pane heading on step change, roving arrow keys that work.
- Contrast failures (detector): Copper Deep on the peach and sage experience cards (3.9:1 and 4.3:1) and the primary button hover (foam on
#c4572b is 4.3:1). Fix: darker hover, espresso price text on tinted cards.
- No mobile navigation on the landing page. Below 960px the section links vanish and nothing replaces them. Fix: a scrollable link row under the header.
- Reveal animation depends on JS.
.reveal is hidden by CSS before JS runs, so with JS failing the page is half blank. Fix: gate hiding on an html.js class.
- Chart values were hover-only in the dashboard, so unavailable on touch and keyboard. Fix: always show values.
P3: Brand coherence and craft
- Emoji icons in the booking preview contradict the PLAN's iconography (rounded 1.75px strokes, one copper accent) and render differently on every OS. Fix: inline SVG icons from the style guide set.
- Italic serif hero (detector: "italic serif display"). The italic second line is the most generic move on the page. Fix: set it roman in copper, and let the cup and the booking card carry personality.
- The style guide does not document the dashboard.
PLAN.md says the dashboard mirrors the tokens, but there is no mapping, no status colour semantics, no dark theme, and no operator components. A designer cannot rebuild the dashboard from it. Fix: add a "Product UI and dashboard" section (token to shadcn variable table, status badges, stat card, schedule block, dark palette).
- Dashboard stat cards on mobile stack to four tall cards before any content; the first useful table is two screens down. Fix: two columns on small screens.
Found while verifying the fixes
- "Upcoming bookings" listed past, completed bookings (Monday's finished jobs came first), so the pending ones an operator must action were below the fold. Fixed: it now shows only today and later, not cancelled or completed, with a link to the full bookings view.
- Hero chip "4.9 avg. rating" was another invented claim. Fixed: replaced with "Fixed prices, GST in".
- Style guide detector findings: thick side border on the do and don't cards, and a skipped heading level in the principles cards. Fixed: full thin borders,
h3 headings.
Resolution status
Items 1 to 15 are all fixed in this pass. Verification: dashboard typecheck, lint and build pass; a headless smoke test drove the booking preview end to end (event $480, full bar $890, focus kept after choosing a time, confirmation announced, no horizontal overflow); desktop, 500px and light and dark screenshots were re-read. Detector warnings that remain were judged: cramped-padding on full-bleed sections (false positive, content is inset by .wrap), overused-font and cream-palette (deliberate brand choices recorded in PLAN.md), and "em-dash overuse" in the style guide (false positive: it counts the --token names, and no U+2014 exists in the project).
Left standing (known, deliberate or out of scope)
- No real photography (none available); imagery is drawn SVG, as
PLAN.md states.
- Schedule has no "now" line, no week navigation and no drag-to-reschedule. It is a view, not a scheduler.
- Customer app screens are only previewed through the booking widget, as planned (non-goal).
- Google Fonts are loaded from the network on the static pages (fallback stack keeps layout stable).